Our goal is to have something for everyone

Current Ice Creams

Click any ice cream for detailed information about that flavor.

Avocado Ice Cream

An extra creamy, sweet and savory ice cream made with ripe avocados!

Cherry Cheesecake Ice Cream

A gorgeous ripple of cherry in a cheesecake ice cream with graham crust pieces.

Cinnamon Heart Ice Cream

A special Valentines day treat.

Cookie Monster Ice Cream

The most unique cookies and cream ice cream you'll ever have! Every scoop is different!

Double-Vanilla Ice Cream

Made with Mexican vanilla, this ice cream has double the vanilla of our other ice creams!

Milk Chocolate Ice Cream

A smooth, milky chocolate ice cream featuring notes of chocolate and allspice for a unique flavor.

Rainbow Bubblegum Ice Cream

Red gumball ice cream featuring little rainbow bits of bubblegum!

Sour Raspberry Ice Cream

Tastes just like blue sour patch kids!

Strawberry Basil Ice Cream

A completely naturally-flavored, unique ice cream!


A scoop in a Waffle Cone or Cup
Like our ice cream, our waffle cones are made fresh in store

Extra Scoops

Pup Cups




Pup Cups
Unflavored frozen yogurt for your furbaby!

Ice Cream Sandwich
Your chosen favorite ice cream flavor between two cookies


Pints of Ice Cream
Flavors vary and may include discontinued or new flavors


Cups of Italian Ice


Ice Cream Heist
A flight of 6 different ice creams - great for 2-4 people!


Ingredients used in all our Ice Cream

Our ice cream is made from scratch and targets about 14% milkfat. Remember: under 10% MF is not ice cream!

Milk, Cream, Skim Milk Powder

Sugar, Dextrose (corn sugar), Salt

Stabilizes the ice crystals. Makes the ice cream smoother.

Egg Yolks, Xanthan Gum, Guar Gum

Sweetens and flavors the ice cream. Makes the ice cream softer.

Can't have ice cream without the dairy!


Coconut Oil

Imparts some flavor, and changes the melting properties.

Retired Flavors

Miss me?  These flavors might come back some day!

Blueberry Muffin
Cotton Candy
Froot Loop
Cherry Cheesecake
Cinnamon Toast Crunch
Coconut Cookies and Cream
Kit Kat Brownie

Lemonade Italian Ice
Pink Lemonade
Old Bay Cornbread
Shark Attack
Watermelon Sorbet

Current Cookies

Click any cookie for detailed information about that type.

No items found.
Coconut Lime Cookies

Sweet with just the right amount of tart

Kitchen Sink Cookie

This cookie contains everything but the kitchen sink!

Mini Egg Cookie

Mini eggs in cookies

Mini New York Chip Cookie

Our Version of a very popular Large cookie that you can get in New York City.

Oreo Chip Cookies

Chopped up Oreos in this soft cookie

Vegan Funfetti Cookies

Our first vegan cookie, so why not make a party cookie

Available in Gluten-Free:


Individual Cookies

4-pack of Cookies

Boxes of Cookies
Minimum of a dozen, price is per cookie



$2.50 ea

Ice Cream Sandwich
Your chosen favorite ice cream flavor between two cookies


Premium Cookies
These cookies are not available in boxes


Retired Cookies

Miss me?  These cookies might come back some day!

Banana Chip
Cranberry Oatmeal Pecan
Joanne's Gingersnap
Chocolate Zucchini
Kit Kat
Pumpkin Spice Snickerdoodle

General Allergen Warning

While we will always have lifestyle and allergy-friendly options, we cannot claim they are completely allergen-free. Because we don't have duplicate equipment, we can only do our best to clean and sanitize between batches.  If you have a severe allergy, please proceed with caution.

Click on any flavor to see the ingredients.  Any additional questions can be answered by contacting us through Twitter or Instagram: @CookieCrimesYQL